Simply Eggless Plant-Based Egg Reviews

(61 customer reviews)

Egg-free, cholesterol-free, cruelty-free vegan egg replacement.

61 reviews for Simply Eggless Plant-Based Egg Reviews

  1. Anonymous

    If you’re looking for a Just Egg replacement, this is not it. I imagine this product might be good for battering something, but that’s about it. On it’s own as a scramble, there is no texture. Very mushy and bland. Bummer!

  2. Anonymous

    Flavorless, scrambles to the wrong texture (like polenta). Very excited to see a Just Egg competitor, but this one does not compete. I didn’t try baking, but from scrambling it doesn’t seem to bind so I doubt it would work for that.

    Please reformulate! I want this to be good so I can do all my shopping at TJs

  3. Roy

    Every so often a product comes along and you wonder how did this ever get out of the lab/test kitchen. Well, Trader Joes Simply Eggless is one of those products. Imagine the most floury gravy you’ve ever tasted, let it thicken even more so that it won’t pour and now you have Trader Joes Simply Eggless. The mouth feel is not pleasant, the taste is almost nonexistent. About the only thing I can compliment them on is the color; some one seems to have remembered that turmeric added to just about anything kinda looks scrambled egg color. Too bad they don’t know about black salt to add some flavor. Honestly, even after adding my own black salt Simply Eggless left me simply disappointed. This product isn’t even close. They should simply start over.

  4. Andrew

    This is no where close to the quality of Just Egg. The texture was similar to that of mashed potatoes and flavor was nonexistent. I added black salt to help make it edible. I would not buy again.

  5. Anonymous

    Amazing!

  6. FreddieFred

    Tasteless + texture is way off (too soft)

    Will not purchase again.

  7. FreddieFred

    I only intended one star

  8. Shirin Eshraghi

    so gross what a waste of money. I usually am not picky at all with food.
    I cooked and cooked hoping the texture would change but it is CREAMY as “scrambled egg.” it feels wrong. Has it gone bad? Confused.
    seems the more i cooked the creamier it got.

    two stars because the ingredients seem good.

  9. Claudia Turner

    I cooked this with all the works- spices, onions, garlic, black pepper, etc- and it was still awful. It’s actually gooey and doesn’t have a good taste. I’m vegan as can be so I’ve tried the gamut of products and this is a really lousy experiment. TJs needs to step up its game with alternative products.

  10. Carol

    Awful! The texture is gummy and gross..no flavor! Stick with JUST egg. Not even close Trader Joe’s

  11. Anonymous

    Simply Eggless is easily the worst product i have ever bought at TJs. It’s hard to believe it ever made it out of a test kitchen. Gummy consistency, difficult to cook with, absent of any flavor, and completely ruined all the vegetables I mixed in for a scramble. I’ll be returning the second bottle I bought.

  12. Jan Johnson

    Remember when Lays “fat free” potato chips were pulled because they had a fake oil called Olean that caused severe stomach issues and diarrhea? Well this “egg” product is sinister in its own way. Look at the ingredients. Lupin is a legume and many people can not digest this. No enzymes in the gut for it. Cattle fodder is its best use.
    There are better egg free alternatives. This is a big no ! And is tasteless. One caveat this is not a Trader Joe’s product. They are just putting it on the shelf satisfying customer demand for an eggless option. Perhaps they will formulate their own product in time.
    In the mean time do you want the following in your body.
    Filtered Water, Lupin Protein Concentrate, High Oleic Sunflower Oil, Gluten Free Beta Glucan, Natural Flavors, Calcium Lactate (Vegan Source), Vegan Enzyme, Tetrasodium Pyrophosphate, Agar, Xanthan Gum, Natural Extractives Of Turmeric, Natural Extractives Of Carrot, Nisin (a Natural Preservative).

  13. Anonymous

    agree with everyone else. Should not be marketed as egg substitute.

  14. Luis

    it tastes horrible. just egg is a million times better

  15. Haley

    Horrible! I had to throw a whole pan of soyrizo mixed with this “egg substitute” away after a few bites The texture is awful and mushy. I added it back to the pan thinking it might need to be cooked a little longer, but it didn’t help whatsoever. I will never buy this again. Just Egg all the way!

  16. Lek Narfs

    There’s eggs and there’s mash potatoes. Both can be soft, smooth and creamy. Simply Eggless is mashed potatoes. The “other” eggless bean-based product widely available is much better at the slightly chewiness of real cooked eggs. This product has none of that. And there’s no eggy flavor at all. As a scramble, this product forms chunks as opposed to a cohesive protien mass like real eggs or the “other” eggless product. A good try but way off the mark.

  17. Cbanaab

    Mixed with stir-fried veggies, spices, and hot sauce, this is delicious! Excited to have an option that is lower fat and much lower sodium than Just Egg.

  18. Noelle

    Healthier egg substitute than Just Egg. My mom really loves it and doesn’t want it discontinued because of the bad reviews. I like it too- worth keeping so that vegans have options. Yummy in an eggless egg sandwich or scramble 🙂

  19. Gloria

    I was super excited to see Trader Joe’s had what I thought was a Just Egg dupe. I’m not vegan, but I love Just Egg and would buy it regularly if it was cheaper. Well, seems like the price point was justified in this comparison because Simply Eggless is disgusting. It doesn’t get anything right, from texture to taste (even after seasoning heavily). I can’t even finish one serving. I’m really disappointed!

  20. Sandra

    This is horrible. We’ve enjoyed Just Egg so I thought I’d give this a try. I’m a huge fan of Trader Joe’s. The texture is like flour mixed with water and oil. A slippery, grainy, gelatinous thing. And there’s no remarkable flavor. Not savory like Just Egg. I just wasted $5.

  21. Jasmine

    This product blows all other vegan egg options out of the park. If you know how to cook it right with a bit of extra virgin olive oil on a non-stick pan it comes out great. I can use it for all my cooking needs like frying or baking. The product pours out of the bottle so smoothly and bright yellow thanks to the healthy Lupini beans and there are no clumps, unlike Just Egg. And its free of all allergens that’s a huge ++++
    10/10 for sure!

  22. Joe

    I was skeptical at first as I eat regular eggs but wanted to try it anyway. First time cooking was not a great result then I did some research and noticed it was best to cook in a hot non stick pan with olive oil. The result was fantastic and not mushy as others have commented on. Maybe a bad batch for some but I’ve cooked omelets and scrambles just fine. A+

  23. Wicket

    I actually really like this product. I’m venturing into Vegetarian/ Vegan territory and this is pretty great. I use it to make omlets and it’s PERFECT for that– love the texture. It’s fluffier than real eggs. I usually season veggies to put in my omlets anyway so it’s a great base for that. Also makes a great omlet if you sprinkle in the Trader Joes Ranch seasoning while you’re cooking.

  24. Rachel

    Tastes like soggy toilet paper and is more expensive than JUST egg.

  25. Jessica

    The texture was terrible. It was mushy and flavorless. I wouldn’t purchase this again. JUST egg is the way to go if you want an egg subsitute.

  26. Ryan

    How did this get released? Hands down the worst Trader Joe’s product I’ve ever had. Mushy, gummy, flavorless. Maybe you could use it in baking or battering, but I doubt it

  27. Patrick

    I echo all the comments of other 1-star reviewers. Stick to Just Egg if you want a plant based egg substitute!

  28. Cindy S

    I’m so confused with all the negative reviews which leads me to wonder if the ones who gave negative reviews knew how to use the product, or even cook! I tried Simple Eggless and it was great, especially with baking. I baked a vegan cake that was so moist and airy, not like most vegan cakes where it would be super dense. My friends raved about the cake and it was all because of Simply Eggless. Just Egg could never do that and so for years, baking vegan cakes was a problem and actually wasn’t common. With this, anything is possible. I love this product! It works so well as an egg alternative and feel bad for those who did not know how to use it. I’m so excited that it made it to Trader Joe’s because now I can get it anytime! I wish it was in local supermarkets so it can always be readily available.

  29. Val

    I would actually give this a negative star and would not recommend it to anyone. The consistency was like mashed potatoes and no flavor considering all the ingredients. Very disappointed in this product when I had high hopes for a vegan egg substitute from Trader Joe’s.

  30. Russ

    I couldn’t stand the curiosity. I finally grabbed s bottle this week and tried it. Utterly ghastly. Like wood glue infused with cardboard. Why does this exist at all much less cost north of $4?

  31. Russ

    I couldn’t stand the curiosity. I finally grabbed a bottle this week and tried it. Utterly ghastly. Like wood glue infused with cardboard. Why does this exist at all much less cost north of $4? This is not food.

  32. RS

    This is horrible. I guess it sort of reminds me of eggs because it’s yellow, but that’s about it. Just Egg, on the other hand, actually tastes like eggs, with an almost identical texture. I’ve never asked for my money back at Trader Joe’s. This may be a first.

  33. Elizabeth

    Honestly, Simply Eggless is one of the better Vegan egg substitutes. I can’t stand Just Egg. The last time I purchased Just Egg it was grainy like sand texture. I’ve never had an issue with how Simply Eggless cooks or tastes. I trust Simply Eggless products more than any other product that substitutes eggs.

  34. Valentina

    Very excited for this product to be at Trader Joe’s. Trader Joe’s has products that are perfect for a person with a busy lifestyle that’s trying to maintain good health and Simpy Eggless has finally arrived along with all other great products. I used to order it online from another store and it would be such a headache. Very impressed with Simply Eggless as it seems the packaging and taste get better formulated. Couldn’t be any more satisfied with this purchase due to the quality and price.

  35. Grace

    THIS IS THE MOST FOUL SMELLING PRODUCT I HAVE EVER COME ACROSS IN MY WHOLE LIFE. I tried using this products weeks before its expiration and it instantly stank up my entire house! I could not even try one single bite of it without gagging. I’ve opened all my windows and lit candles, but the smell won’t go away. I have NEVER smelled anything worse in my life!!!

  36. Bre

    I’m so glad I’m not the only one complaining about the texture with this product! I just made it for the second time because I thought maybe the first it was user error but NO! I was surprised and excited to see this at TJ so I thought I would give it a try over the usual just egg but the mushiness in my mouth is just NOT IT. I had to throw it out. Please try to reformulate this.

  37. NYC Vegan

    Surprisingly bad. I am shocked that a wonderful place like Trader Joe’s would even bring this to market. I’m sure they must have tried the Just Egg product before releasing this. What were they thinking?

    I had a really tough time getting through the entire bottle. I even tried mixing this with the Just Egg before cooking, and it simply ruined the Just Egg.

    I have since probably gone through 10 or 20 bottles of Just Egg. I am a big user LOL! I love that stuff.

    I’ll keep an eye out for a reformulation from TJ’s.

  38. Sophie

    I really am surprised how well this product was thought out. Not only can I quickly whip up some ‘eggs’ in a pan but I can also bake with it too! very multiuse which is a game changer.

  39. Srini Rao

    Who are the people who are giving it positive reviews.. Has to be fake. I thought I was using it all wrong at first but after reading the reviews I realize it’s a terrible product. This reminds me how they messed up morning star sausage patties and tried selling them as original.. So awful..

  40. CJ

    I bought this product a few weeks ago and just hot around to trying it. I prepared it like scrambled eggs. I added some shredded cheddar cheese, salt and pepper. I thought it was delicious. I will absolutely buy this product again and enjoy this every few days for breakfast. I do hope it is not discontinued as this is the first egg substitute I have really enjoyed.

  41. Sue Mascitelli

    The nastiest thing I have ever tried from Trader Joe’s! The texture, the smell how it cooks up, Blech! I wasted my ingredients for my omelette because it all ended up in the trash! Please bring back the liquid egg you carried before!

  42. James Saupan

    Sorry Trader Joe’s, back to the drawing board. This product is a gooey mess. Definitely didn’t scramble in any way shape or form. Texture is chewy, rubbery and tasteless. Added my spices, but that was a waste of spices.
    Love Trader Joe’s for vegan varieties, but this product is a no repeat.

  43. Anonymous

    Absolutely disgusting texture and taste. Please just get Just Egg.

  44. Steph

    Not as bad as all the reviewers say. Just Egg is better. Especially Just Egg’s frozen egg patties but this is a decent alternative. Now, I probably would not eat a plate of this by itself. It’s not good enough for that but it’s good in a breakfast burrito. Husband and kids liked it too so I’ll keep buying it but I do hope Trader Joe’s comes out with something a little closer to Just Egg in consistency since that can be enjoyed by itself.

  45. Kevin

    Looks bad.
    Smell was so off-putting I couldn’t get myself to even taste it after pan scrambling it’s like you would with eggs or just egg.
    It smelled like some type of familiar chemical, maybe wood or wood glue ?
    Texture was glue like or rubbery but not like scrambled eggs.
    It was also kind of translucent, not egg like at all.
    Maybe in baking you could get away with it.
    We even wasted the first one because it expired, got a second one and made sure we used it before we forgot we had it.
    I like many other reviewers thought maybe it was a bad batch or a teething problem, but my wife just said we will not even think about trying it again.
    I can’t properly voice just how bad it was.
    I love Trader Joe’s but somebody dropped the ball on this.
    Please fix it since it would be nice to have a credible competitor for just egg.

  46. Jim

    If you love the taste of rubber drenched in oil, this is the product for you! If you love sending people the green puke emoji you’re about to get sore thumbs. It’s as if the people who made this product are secretly working for the egg industry trying to convince people to never try a humane analog product ever again. I really hope whoever greenlit this product gets hired by Arbys or some other producer of dead animal “food”.

  47. Siri

    Worst product ever at TJ’s. Still love TJ’s. Basically plant based but this is horrific. Makes a pancake like texture and tastes like what I imagine the bottom of a gym shoe in a locker room would taste like. Yuk. Just egg is a different ball game. But keep trying TJ for more plant based vegan options. Appreciate the effort, not the outcome.

  48. Lauren

    Made me sick for 2 hours. It’s nasty.

  49. Robert

    Best vegan eggs I’ve tried. I cannot understand the negative reviews. Curious that many of the negative reviews repeat claims that seemed to be the opposite of my experience. The texture is excellent. I have scrambled it and fried it in a circular form for putting on English muffins. It holds up better than any premixed vegan eggs I have tried.

  50. Roberta Parch

    Simply Awful is what they should’ve named this. I’ve been vegetarian/ vegan for many years and this is the worst substitute for anything I’ve ever tried. UGH

  51. LeeDan

    By far one of the worst things I have ever purchased. Disgusting. Tastes like what play doh smells like. Texture is weird. No amount of hot sauce, spice, herb, will make this edible. Such a waste. Don’t do it.

  52. Anonymous

    I’ve used just egg a lot and when Trader Joe’s wasn’t caring it I grabbed this. A
    With eggs and just eggs I tend to take make the same baked egg dish of red peppers, mushroom, onion and pesto. At this point I’m sad I ruined the rest of my ingredients. Got a little solid after ten minutes so kept my on it at 375.. 5 minutes later still runny. 5 minutes lates still runny and had a car board like taste. 5 minutes later still mush consistently. Put it on low broil for five minutes and it firmed up the top thin layer a bit. Still gross tasting and mushy :(. So disappointed as I enjoy so many tj products

  53. Sandra

    I really am enjoying this product. One of the best egg replacers I’ve used thus far!

  54. Tash Nah

    HAS ANYONE BAKED A CAKE WITH THIS?

  55. Emily

    Honestly, all you have to do is know how to put some oil in a pan and lightly pour this product in the pan evenly on a medium temperature. High enough to cook but not burn, obviously. Gradually stir the egg around until fully cooked. If you overpour too fast and thick your results are not going to be what you desire. It’s very simple and the name really fits the product. Simply Eggless is a simple product to use and yet people can’t use it right. it’s not the product, it’s people not knowing how to use the product.

  56. Sandi G.

    Much better than Just Egg. Maybe the negative reviews are by people who aren’t vegan? Simply Eggless doesn’t stick like Just Egg, it tastes better, and is delicious scrambled with veggies and topped with vegan cheese.

  57. Christina

    Absolutely disgusting! I’m actually offended. The audacity of everyone involved in putting these plant-based eggs on store shelves!! I literally spit them out and gagged. The smell was bad, but I figured I’d still give them a taste. Just… Yuck! I have no more words.

  58. Shauntell T

    Really enjoying this new to-the-market product. Best Egg replacer I’ve tried so far. It’s great because not only is it as easy as ever to make scrambled eggs but MY KIDS even eat them! My life has been simplified. Must try!

  59. Jenna

    I mistakenly gave this a few try’s wanting it to be a good eggless option. Threw it away after one bite every time. I found myself wondering, much like the other reviews state, how on earth did a group of people at Simply Brands let this hit the shelves? This product has a horrible, horrible powdery -almost clay like taste to it. The texture is so slimy, greasy, and mushy. Just wrong in every way.
    Save your time, money, and taste buds. Do not buy.

  60. Trix

    So the first taste test… RUBBER… probably because of the xanthan gum and other ingredients.

    HOWEVER, I did manage to make it ‘more edible’ by only using two tbsps of the mixture and 2 tbsp water + 1/8 tsp black salt.

    I want to continue experimenting but it’s giving me a serious upset stomach…

  61. Yolanda

    No need for me to repeat everything negative (and VERY correct!) that has already been said about this product so, my two cents…this product is made for folks who have a dull palate and reject flavor in their meals. I added (more like, dumped) a spice medley & two helpings of salt to enhance the flavor of spices and STILL, blandness dominated the taste of the finished product. DO NOT BUY! Just EGG is where it’s at, buy that instead! Lastly, I hope TJ discontinues this product, SMH.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like…