Trader Joe’s Fully Baked Chicken Pot Pie Reviews

2.2 out of 5 based on 15 customer ratings
(15 customer reviews)

Category: .


15 reviews for Trader Joe’s Fully Baked Chicken Pot Pie Reviews

  1. Sabrina
    4 out of 5

    :

    Our family tried the Chicken Pot Pie and it was very good.

  2. Krista L Pendino
    5 out of 5

    :

    This was awsome! Cooked in 25 minutes. So easy to make for my family even after working a 10 hour day. And it looked and tasted homeade. My husband, 12 year old and 2 year old all loved it! I did buy two because my family can eat. Plus I was able to take left overs to work.

  3. Barbara Hollowed
    5 out of 5

    :

    Buttery crust, big pieces of chicken, nice fresh veggies with a creamy flavorful sauce.

  4. Kate Camp
    2 out of 5

    :

    Sorry–not nearly as good as the previous version. A slab of crust, not very tender; chicken was tough and tasteless. Disappointed in this new version–loved the previous one!

  5. max malloy
    2 out of 5

    :

    my wife bought chicken pot pie and heated via microwave. the crust was impossible to cut, even with a bread knife. the old version was a lot better. the ingredients was the same as the old version, but the crust was a disaster.

  6. Sue b
    3 out of 5

    :

    Why o why did they change the crust?.. Used to be so good but now is blah.Bring back the crispy puffy buttery crust

  7. nine sherlee
    2 out of 5

    :

    they changed the recipe and it’s not NEARLY as good as the original. Much less chicken, and crust not nearly as flaky. Used to go to TJ’s just to purchase their fresh pot pie. Won’t bother now. Another corporate “cheap out”

  8. Marissa
    1 out of 5

    :

    Terrible. The filling was almost foam like and there was no flavor- it needed salt and pepper. Will not purchase again.

  9. Suzanne Benson
    1 out of 5

    :

    Loved the “original” version! Bring back flacky crust. And flavor. Will NOT buy again!

  10. Suzanne Benson
    1 out of 5

    :

    Also three huge slice of potatoe raw!!

  11. Robin
    1 out of 5

    :

    My husband, who eats everything, was very excited about this. But while it was cooking (we followed the instructions to bake in the oven) there was an odd odor that didn’t smell like chicken, smelled more like rotten fish. When it was done, we dished up and he took one bite and for the first time ever had to spit it out. He never spits out his food, and usually powers through anything, but he gagged immediately. I didn’t even bother to try it after seeing his reaction as I already was turned off by the odor. We had to dump it out and take it out to the garbage as it smelled up our house. The taste was one of the worst things we ever tasted. He described the flavor as what he would expect poop to taste like. The expiration date said 4/4, which is in 3 more days, so it wasn’t past expiration. Won’t buy again. Ruined our dinner for the night, had to scramble to make something else.

  12. Gabriella
    1 out of 5

    :

    It tastes like poop it was completely inedible we had to make PB & J’s after our Family tried it. We were so disappointed and my dad ate the when pie and we hope he doesn’t get sick and die.

  13. Gabriella
    1 out of 5

    :

    It tastes like poop it was completely inedible we had to make PB & J’s after our Family tried it. We were so disappointed and my dad ate the whole pie and we hope he doesn’t get sick and die.

  14. Tiffany Saito
    2 out of 5

    :

    WHY did you mess with perfection?!?

    What the heck fugue state was behind the decision to take the BEST PART OF THE PIE OFF THE PIE?!?!
    NO PUFF PASTRY CRUST?????

    I wanted to weep.

    And now there is too much chicken and it’s dry. One tiny piece of potatoe? Hardly any mushrooms?

    Major let down.

    You ruined my dinner.
    And this product.
    You should lower the price.
    This is now only worth $5.

  15. Maria
    2 out of 5

    :

    We picked up a family favorite, Chicken pot pie for dinner and we were all so sad. I notice the package was different and it was a $1 cheaper but didn’t think they had actually changed anything. They replaced the buttery flakey crust with a doughy topper. The filling didn’t even come up half way. Such a disappointment!

Add a review