Trader Joe’s Vegan Mayo Spread & Dressing Reviews

(19 customer reviews)

Ingrdients: avocado oil, water, chickpea broth (water, chickpeas), white vinegar, sea salt, natural flavors, mustard flour, lemon juice concentrate, gum arabic, xanthan gum, garlic powder, onion powder, rosemary, oleoresin, and black pepper.

Category: Tags: , ,

19 reviews for Trader Joe’s Vegan Mayo Spread & Dressing Reviews

  1. Anonymous

    If you’re vegetarian don’t waste your time with this Mayo. Just go for the real thing. This mayo has too strong of a vinegar flavor. Nothing else comes through. The calories are also about the same per serving between this and regular mayo so I would never buy this again. Just make your own regular or vegan mayo at home.

  2. lori

    More sour than real mayonnaise and the texture is more… chunky (it is not smooth). I’ve only had my jar for about a month and it is now separating — liquid is pooling around curds of mayo. I do not recommend.

  3. Danielle du Preez

    I use this to mix in with other things. For example, I use it to make chickpea salad. That’s already a sour dish, so the fact that this is sour doesn’t make much difference to me. Definitely does not compare to Vegenaise, but neither does any other vegan mayo. I would rate this a solid “not bad” and I’m grateful that Trader Joes finally has SOME vegan mayo option.

  4. Julie

    It’s chunky, and had a weird plastic flavor and aftertaste. Do not recommend!!!

  5. PF

    I literally buy this mayo all the time from TJ’s. It’s the best one I’ve found. I don’t find it to be too sour or vinegar tasting. I LOVE using it for my chickpea sandwich spread, I make salad dressings with it, and use it for tuna salad (for the few times I eat meat). I did have one incident when it separated in the jar and I couldn’t get it to combine again and become smooth. That happened once (out of the 10 jars I’ve bought over the last year). I just took it back and they let me swap it out for another jar – no questions, no charge. I buy this product because most other brands have an off taste to me.

  6. Eric Brightwell

    The flavor is decent (I like things sour and vinegary) — similar, in my opinion, to Follow Your Heart’s Vegenaise or Hellmann’s Vegan Mayonnaise. The appearance, though, is… not good. It has a slightly grayish color and after about a week in my fridge, it’s curdling with oil coming to the surface and chunky bits forming below. It still tastes fine, though, if you can ignore the appearance.

  7. Nannette LeBlanc

    Its taste horrible..

  8. Maura

    Everyone saying this has a vinegar flavor.. But I don’t think it does. It tastes like someone mixed Mayo with a little mustard so it’s great in sandwiches and such!

  9. Jo

    This stuff is disgusting! I’m sticking with Vegenaise.

  10. TL

    SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOo GROSS!the smell is like pure super glue .Dont buy this!!!!
    Tell store manger all reviews are bad.I had to pick arating but there isnt on for I picked one star

  11. Rita Childers

    This stuff is vile. There’s way too much vinegar. You can even smell it when you open the jar. Please, please, please bring back the original Trader Joe’s Vegan Mayo Spread and Dressing. You should never have messed with a good thing!

  12. Marina

    I’m aurprised by the negative reviews. This is the best vegan mayo option since Just Mayo in my opinion. Great in spinach dip, as a caesar salad dressing base and it has that eggy flavor that leans more APV than plasticy fake mayo of competitors. This is still better and less ofensive to me than the smell of Veganaise and Best Foods vegan mayo (which ironically should be better since I think they shut down/bought “just mayo”). Outside of this it’s probably best to just make your own vegan mayo.

  13. NYC Vegan

    I want to like it but I just can’t get there. The main flavor that comes through is vinegar, but it’s just overall not a tasty mayo. I much prefer Vegenaise, which I stll think is the absolute best in the business.

    I’m wondering if there is a fix for this mayo….maybe adding a little simply syrup or something to offset the vinegar taste.

  14. Cyndi

    Trader Joe’s used to have the best vegan mayo. For while, it was unavailable. I guess they replaced it with this. This is terrible!!!!!! I do not recommend. Such a disappointment. I tried to give it a zero star rating, but this site does not allow it!

  15. Deborah Ebersold

    I use it as a mayo substitute!

  16. Kathy Carver

    Really love this mayo. Better ingredients! No soybean oil or canola. I like the tartness. I

  17. LJ White

    I have been using vegan mayo for at least 5 years and this is one of my favorites! The comments about vinegar taste were not present in my mayo experience. Keep making amazing vegan products, TJs!

  18. vicente

    i love this vegan mayo – no bad ingredients and tastes great in my sandwiches and everything u would use mayo for !

  19. Rach

    Does anyone know if this was discontinued? I loved it and my TJs never carries it anymore I’m so bummed!!!

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like…