Trader Joe’s Peanut Butter Brookie Reviews

(5 customer reviews)

Fudgy brownie batter topped with peanut butter cookie batter baked together for a sweet combination: peanut butter brookies!

Category: Tag:

5 reviews for Trader Joe’s Peanut Butter Brookie Reviews

  1. Christine

    chewy gooey peanut butter cookie with peanuts and sprinkled sea salt onto of a very moist, also semi-gooey, brownie base. So, so, so good!

  2. Sherry

    Out of this world! You will not be disappointed! Although, I was because I truly remember a cookie dough topping instead of peanut butter, so I was expecting & wanting that. Not sure why they changed it, but in the end, still ended up being really good. I ate most in one day! Except one square! Not that I couldn’t have! ….They had most of them expiring the next day. I wondered if they discount bakeries when expired. I would’ve surely taken them home anything expired or maybe the employees enjoy them. I did read they do give away but not sure specifically of each store. Well, you can consider me an option in the plainview/hicksville NY store please 🙂

  3. RyanOtter

    delicious peanut butter cookie w/ chewy chocolate brownie and a hint of sea salt! Delicious!!! I could have eaten an entire tray!

  4. Paula

    Not impressed. Sea salt is overpowering nd the peanut butter cookie part was not cooked enough. Is like dough on a brownie.

  5. L

    Chewy love the salted taste

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like…