Search from over 5,000 products and 10,000+ ratings! Not affiliated with Trader Joe's.
– December 8, 2015
I had high hopes for this cheesecake but I found it to be bland and felt it had a rubbery texture.
– January 27, 2019
I tried a sample of this when I was in Trader Joe’s and it’s delicious!! If I ever have a dinner party, this will be perfect and it’s a good price! I’m scared to buy one otherwise ,because I’ll just eat it all in two days.
– August 5, 2019
Disappointing. The only flavor is a coying sweetness. I don’t get any sense of vanilla, or lemon, or almond, nothing except an overload of sugar. Excessive sugar affected its texture negatively. The crumb crust also has too much sugar, and no butter flavor. Please stop relying on heavy sugar as an excuse and substitute for any real flavors.
– September 19, 2020
I too was disappointed in Trader Joe’s New York cheesecake. I was excited to try it and brought it over to a friend’s to celebrate our birthday’s together. We both thought is was bland and the Graham cracker crust was not very good either.
– October 8, 2020
WHY DID THEY STOP OFFERING THE CHEESECAKE IN THE “WHITE BOX?” I WAS MUCH BETTER AND HAD THE ORIGINAL NEW YORK STYLE TASTE – DON’T BOTHER WITH THE “BLUE BOX” OR JUST BY SARA LEE’S AND SAVE THE TRIP
– August 25, 2021
Rubbery and gross. It’s like they added cheesecake flavoring to paste.
– October 29, 2021
I love this cheese cake!!!!!!! I always get it for my birthday! You can’t make one for this price!
– December 2, 2021
Positives – good tasting crust and not too much sugar for me. Negative – very bland cheesecake. Entire family of 4 disappointed.
– January 26, 2022
New York plain cheese cake from Trader Joe’s is 100% excellent!
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Your review *