Search from over 5,000 products and 15,000+ ratings! Not affiliated with Trader Joe's.
– March 19, 2016
This was really good – different than the typical Kraft type, but a nice change of pace. Very gooey and tasty.
– June 24, 2022
This used to be the best mac n cheese on the market. Then they changed the formulation of the cheese packet. Now it is absolutely disgusting. Mac n cheese should not be sweet!!! It’s grainy, too. ncredibly disappointing, this used to be a staple comfort food for me.
– June 28, 2022
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE! Trader Joes return to Wisconsin cheddar! I travel all the way down from Canada to buy this and am super disappointed with the new product.
– June 29, 2022
Please, please, please, change it back to Wisconsin cheddar, original noodles, too. This was a weekly staple at our house, 2-3 boxes per week, easy. No one likes the new formulation. We are all so sad. 🙁
– July 1, 2022
My children are picky eaters. The old Wisconsin Mac n Cheese was great. Nothing could replace it. I just made what I though was the same Trader Joe’s Mac n Cheese only to be horribly disappointed. It’s not just the cheese that’s different- the pasta is nearly gray and thinner. It smells funny and tastes bad. They also added Soybean oil. I feel betrayed. We will not buy this as it is ever again.
– July 15, 2022
Terrible! This was a weekly staple, now I’ve tried two different boxes and was seriously disappointed. I tried to dress it up with more butter, and melting cheese, but it didn’t work. It was sweet, funny tasting, and the noodles were grainy. I will not be buying this again! My kids are so very sad!
– July 25, 2022
I agree with everyone – I actually just got online to see if this new formulation was grossing others out. We used to buy 13 at a time (a baker’s dozen- it was a family funny!) now I don’t even think we will finish what we bought this past weekend.
Bring back Wisconsin Cheddar!!
– August 2, 2022
Argh! What happened? My daughter knew it had changed the moment the new Mac and cheese came out….and it went from being her favorite food to something she won’t touch! Please change it back!!!
– August 12, 2022
My grand daughter called the original Wisconsin Cheddar Mac and cheese “grandmas special Mac & cheese ” she actually cried when I made the new formula for her. Please bring back the original
– November 18, 2022
bring back the old formula. this is genuinely a ruined product. tastes like every other cheap mac and cheese product. whoever made this decision is stupid.
– January 8, 2023
T.J’S “PLEASE” listen to these customers reviews……
A favored store item has gone from great to terrible, like many or most will NEVER purchase again it’s AWFUL and disappointing to loyal customers PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD or loose sales.
– April 12, 2023
Absolutely awful, CHANGE THE RECIPE BACK!
– June 2, 2023
I agree with all the negative reviews. It is now so terrible, I am throwing it away and will never buy again unless they return to the original formula. It does have an awful sweet taste. Everything is different and bad. I gave a box to someone to try after raving about it and they thought I was nuts. I hadn’t yet tried the new changed product. TJ’s needs to remove this from their shelves.
– October 18, 2023
It was my favorite Mac n cheese, and I would eat it at least every other week. For years. Then I tried the “new” one last year and it was so bad I thought it was spoiled. After two bites I tossed it, made another box, took one bite and spit it out.
It is foul.
I couldn’t even donate the remaining 3 boxes to the food bank because I genuinely believe this is Not fit for human consumption.
Would really love if it was restored… I miss it.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Your review *