Trader Joe’s All Butter Sugar Cookie Dough Reviews

(16 customer reviews)

Ready to bake – do not eat raw.

Categories: ,

16 reviews for Trader Joe’s All Butter Sugar Cookie Dough Reviews

  1. Dee

    The batches I bought have 2 different exp dates. The Oct one is very disappointing. Has a very weird taste that even my homemade frosting can’t cover. I can’t even place what it is. I hope the Nov exp date ones might be different and will let you know.

  2. Anonymous

    I agree completely with review on 10/14/23. I am extremely disappointed n this product.( Exp. Date 10(23/23) the cookie has a very odd taste. Even my husband said the same thing, and he likes anything sweet. I also can’t figure out what I am tasting, but I threw out the cookie after 1 bite.
    I’ll love Trader’s Joes but I will be going back for a refund on this product.

  3. Steph

    I agree with the other 2 reviews. The dough smelled weird from the package. Smelled the same way through baking. It smells like yeast. I thought maybe I got too close to the expiration date which is today (10/23). However it looks like the other reviews had the same reaction and they used their dough sooner. They taste better than they smell, but there is still an ‘off’ taste. Bummer! I wanted cookies!

  4. Dee

    Not sure how to update my first review but the second batch was just as odd tasting.

  5. Anonymous

    Hate them. Probably the worst store bought cookies ever produced. They have a weird texture and an odd smell and taste. Like some other reviewers, I’m also unable to place the flavor. It’s indescribable, though trust me when I say it’s bad. Effing awful.

  6. Brittany

    Unfortunately did not like this product. Smells like Mac and cheese. Doesn’t taste as bad as it smells but def not my favorite

  7. Julie

    Made my house smell like cheese and we’re inedible. The taste was better than the smell but it was so off that I was afraid to eat anymore. Literally threw away the whole batch.

  8. Erin

    Smells like rancid milk and tastes like vomit.

  9. a

    Agreed smelly, almost fermented when opening the package and after baking had a very off taste

  10. Deborah stjern

    I love trader Joe’s! I also love sugar cookies. This tasted NOTHING like a sugar cookie. Not even remotely. I threw away the ones I made and the rest of the dough. I don’t know how any person could taste these, and think they were good!! Terribly disappointed!

  11. J.G.

    The smell of this cookie dough is extremely bad. The closest thing I can relate it to is milk vomit. I could not bring myself to try them because of the bad smell. My whole house smells like vomit. The dough is not expired either.

  12. Sue Holmes

    If I could give this cookie dough a negative rating, I would. It tastes like black walnuts that are rancid. Off+brand/generic brands of cookie dough taste much better. I wish that I had returned the unused portion fr a refund. Instead, I tried sprinkling dried lemon peel and sugar on top before baking the see if that helped. No luck. I also had to chisel the cookies off my baking pans.

  13. Leslie Ippolito

    I thought I would be the only one that as soon as I opened the package; smells pretty sour. I baked 5 cookies but I didn’t want to risk it and threw them/ cookie dough away.

  14. Anonymous

    Tastes and smells spoiled. Threw them away after baking seemed not to remedy the problem.

  15. Ramona

    Awful taste like a artificial flavor, would not buy again.

  16. R.K.

    Don’t buy…these are the worst ever. I agree with the milk vomit comment. Just wasted $8 dollars and my time. They went in the garbage.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like…