Search from over 5,000 products and 10,000+ ratings! Not affiliated with Trader Joe's.
– September 19, 2016
Let me first say that my husband loves all your pasta sauces.
As for me, this sauce is big on spice but the flavor is not very robust. The tomato taste is strong, but in addition to the biting taste, what’s missing? Because of this I tend to lose interest in my pasta meal and I sometimes leave a bit behind, which is unusual for me.
– January 1, 2017
just yuck..hated this sauce.. the one star review is for the no hassle full refund!
– February 23, 2017
1st, I have tried many, many pasta sauces everywhere that would give me a great Lasagna taste of real Italian. OMG I am done looking I will never buy another sauce again, this was fantastic . I don’t even have words to say how tasty this was, I’m going back to the store and see if I can buy a case. Loved it, loved it, loved it……….. If I could I would give this taste a 15 star. yes I would
– November 30, 2017
Our favorite pasta sauce, a strong robust flavor with enough chunk to feel like it’s not from a jar. We always have a jar in the pantry.
– January 25, 2019
Weird smelling,tast okay.
Got sick, about half hour after eating.
Then i remember my mom telling me, be careful eating Trader Joe’s products.Has a reputation of giving people food Poisoning.
Especially if the product is from overseas.
I think this pasta sauce is from overseas.
– January 28, 2019
We love this sauce! Won’t buy any other brand jar sauce again!
– December 4, 2019
Read the label: Italian plum tomatoes are the first ingredient, as they should be, not sauce made of tomato paste and water. Another Italian sauce this good out of the jar would cost at least twice as much.
– September 15, 2020
My favorite sauce. Disappointed when they didn’t have it in stock on my last visit….hopefully restocking soon. LOVE IT!
– October 10, 2021
My absolute bar none favorite pasta sauce. Fantastic flavor which can be eaten right out of the jar, or you can doctor it with some onions, garlic, pepper…. simply delicious. Unfortunately Rustico has been out of stock due to a glass jar issue. Hope it comes back.
– December 16, 2021
Yuck. Watery and bad flavor, I’m forcing myself to finish my plate right now. The remaining noodles are in a pool of water.
– April 4, 2022
Absolutely love this sauce. Great flavor. Can’t find it anymore. Very disappointed about this. I hope you will bring it back.
– May 7, 2022
WHY WHY WHY CAN YOU NOT FIND THIS SAUCE AT TRADER JOES ANYMORE???? I AM FURIOUS!
– June 5, 2022
wish TJ’s would stop discontinuing great staples like this.
– June 23, 2022
REALLY miss T.J.’s Rustico sauce. I’ve now tried 4 other brands of sauce but none measure up.
– October 20, 2022
I miss this sauce it is the best!
When is it coming back!!!!!!
Cook Italian cook
– October 20, 2022
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Your review *