Search from over 5,000 products and 15,000+ ratings! Not affiliated with Trader Joe's.
– October 20, 2015
Absolutely awesome! these never last more than a couple days at my house.
– May 24, 2016
Ahhhh-mazing! Best p.b. cups ever
– July 26, 2017
Do we really need to review these? I feel like it is a joke. Of course they are amazing. Dark chocolate + peanut butter = good
– November 24, 2017
I love these, but not everyone appreciates the dark chocolate. (That means more for me, right?)
I’d buy them more often if the package was half the size. Instead, I usually get the much smaller single-serving package.
– December 28, 2019
So yummy! The best of both worlds, peanut butter and dark chocolate!
– March 5, 2020
These are so good! The peanut butter is not too sweet. The dark chocolate is delicious and, they don’t have that Reese’s aftertaste.
– June 9, 2021
These are just awful… awful good!
Forget all the other peanut butter cups. These are the ones to get.
Try em, you’ll like em.
– December 14, 2021
The gold standard by which all chocolate PB cups should be measured. Although I’d love to try the dark chocolate almond butter cups, just can’t find ’em.
– February 4, 2022
I think I read somewhere this is TJ’s best selling product of all time. It’s very easy to see why when you eat one. I think, and most people do, the dark chocolate is better than the milk chocolate. These are mind blowing, life changing cups. Just be sure to try to moderate; these are insanely addictive. Probably my #1 item GOAT pick.
– February 4, 2022
Here’s a tip – freeze them, eat the chocolate around the sides first, then the peanut butter. Great way to make them last a little longer! 😉
– March 18, 2022
Staple in the freezer. Have created some unintentional expectations in the household. God forbid they ever disappear.
– September 20, 2022
I wish I didn’t love these so much but they’re just so dang good
– October 28, 2022
Beyond belief. Most addictive TJ product ever!
– November 26, 2022
I love these and eat them every week
– December 14, 2022
Oh gosh these might be my favorite candy ever. They are SO GOOD! I only wish they made mini ones of these (they only make the mini in milk chocolate) so I could use them in baked goods more easily.
– January 23, 2023
Flipping awesome. I keep them in my freezer for my go-to treat. Always buy these when I stop by Trader Joe’s.
– January 31, 2023
The best Trader Joe’s item that ever lived! I’ve been a Reese’s fan for my entire life… until I met these. The peanut butter is so smooth and perfect. The dark chocolate is very high quality and most importantly, the peanut butter to chocolate ratio is spot on! Buy these with caution: you might become addicted too!
– September 2, 2023
My company produces the Trader Joe’s PB cups. They are by far the best ever! And I live 20 miles from Hershey Pa where Reese’s PB cups are produced and everyone I share these with is blown away about how much better they are .
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Your review *