Trader Joe’s Organic American Cheese Slices Reviews

(12 customer reviews)

Category: Tag:

12 reviews for Trader Joe’s Organic American Cheese Slices Reviews

  1. Jon

    There are no reviews on this product? Good. That means no one is buying it. Trader Joe’s is my hands down favorite place for groceries. I have never had a lame product…until now. This cannot be cheese. It tastes like plastic, chews like plastic, and looks like plastic. This stuff is sad. It does not melt and is tasteless. Never again for me or anyone I know. If you waste your money on this product, THAT’S on you.

  2. TQ

    I didn’t know that this cheese was gonna be bad. I thought I was getting something like Kraft singles for burgers but the cheese did not melt and tasted bad and it wasn’t even good to eat cold either. Please discontinue this product.

  3. M Butler

    I had bought this cheese for years and they were good. The packages I got this year were horrible. Hard practice texture and they don’t melt! I am not buying this product again.

  4. Jon Andrews

    Something strange happened between grocery runs. This product has been consistently great as long as I can remember. These last few weeks, a switch flipped and it’s completely different. It’s now stiff, with no flavor and will not melt. After reading other reviews, at least I know I’m not going crazy.

  5. Jim

    It’s sad when a good product goes bad…
    This was my goto American Cheese for years, and now it appears I will have to choose an alternative, as TJs branded American Cheese has most likely been contracted out to another vendor or they have altered the chemistry of the product…
    It refuses to melt and resembles a floor tile instead of a slice of cheese, and it has an almost chemical taste to it…
    I’ve seen a few great items at TJs that have come and gone, or the product was changed to the point that it was no longer on my shopping list…
    I was truly sad to see the blueberry bran muffins go extinct, but it would of been tragic if it had been replaced by an inferior product…
    As with this particular item; I would of preferred that it just go away, rather than what it has become…

  6. Jojo

    bad cheese. only 12 slices. doesn’t melt. and takes shape of the package. it says “cheese product” so that should’ve been its red flag. tastes like dollar tree cheese. they should definitely discontinue this. I wish i got kraft instead.

  7. Amanda

    Bought this cheese 2 months ago for the first time and it was great. Melted perfectly like singles cheese should. Something happened with how the cheese is made because now it suddenly doesn’t melt at all, and has no taste. Discontinue this and get a better American singles cheese option please!

  8. Wendy

    I have been buying this for years and loving it. Bought it recently and it is bad terrible awful! Nothing like before. I hated it so much I had to go search online to see if I was alone in this (maybe losing my mind or taste buds). Luckily I found all these terrible reviews. Trader Joe’s please respond. What did you change? And please change it back!

  9. Chris

    I don’t know what happened, this used to be a reliably good cheese. Easily meltef. Good on burgers. Now it won’t budge. No matter how much heat is applied it doesn’t melt, not in the oven on a griddle, not with steam. It just remains a rubbery square, or if you leave it cooking long enough, it burns, at best. I miss the old cheese

  10. Lynn Larson

    I made a grilled cheese sandwich today with TJ’s American cheese and was confounded as to why the cheese wouldn’t melt. I google searched for this issue and to my great surprise, this site came up with all of these comments. I love Trader Joe’s and I have never complained before. Is this a quality control issue? Please respond and fix this!

  11. D

    This is the worst cheese I’ve ever had in my life
    is so disgusting even my cats won’t eat it

  12. Eileen Donahoe

    I literally burned up my frying pan trying to melt this cheese on my hamburger. What happened? The reviews say this cheese was good in April. What happened since then. Every one of these bad reviews are correct.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *