9 reviews for Trader Joe’s Apple Crumble Pie Reviews
Rated 5 out of 5
Jose –
Great pie to pair with vanilla ice cream. Feels like a personally baked pie. Quite amazed.
Rated 1 out of 5
Medric Brauer –
Nauseatingly sweet. Apples were decent, but the goo and crumble were way too sweet.
Rated 2 out of 5
Anonymous –
Had a sample and it was really sweet.
Rated 5 out of 5
Alyssa –
Really good. Maybe too sweet on its own, but really good with vanilla ice cream.
Rated 1 out of 5
ronn –
too sweet for sure. didnt realize it had oats-this is more akin to a Cliff Bar then a pie.
wont buy again. Had apple pie last yr at TJs and enjoyed it. Ill buy elsewhere in the future.
Rated 5 out of 5
Rowena Umipig-Matias –
I love this so much!! The oat crumble is perfect…so chewy and not too sweet at all.
Rated 3 out of 5
Caroline –
This pie got a serious downgrade in 2024. All the apples are now sliced paper thin, destroying the wonderful texture baked Northern Spy wedges get. I can’t say for sure, but it also seems like there’s less apple and more crumble this year. And this has the unfortunate side effect of making a borderline-too-sweet pie even sweeter. Still a solid premade pie, but disappointing.
Rated 3 out of 5
W –
Eh, not nearly as good as I was hoping for given the “buttery oat crumble” description on the package. I love apple pies that have that kind of top, but this one was pretty hard (and not just pleasantly crunchy), at least the one I got. I tried it both room-temp and also heated up with vanilla ice cream. It was okay, but not something I’d buy again and definitely not as good as most apple pies I’ve had.
Rated 3 out of 5
S –
Had a sample. More like a 3.5. A bit sweet like 8/10 in terms of sweetness. Otherwise a decent pie.
Jose –
Great pie to pair with vanilla ice cream. Feels like a personally baked pie. Quite amazed.
Medric Brauer –
Nauseatingly sweet. Apples were decent, but the goo and crumble were way too sweet.
Anonymous –
Had a sample and it was really sweet.
Alyssa –
Really good. Maybe too sweet on its own, but really good with vanilla ice cream.
ronn –
too sweet for sure. didnt realize it had oats-this is more akin to a Cliff Bar then a pie.
wont buy again. Had apple pie last yr at TJs and enjoyed it. Ill buy elsewhere in the future.
Rowena Umipig-Matias –
I love this so much!! The oat crumble is perfect…so chewy and not too sweet at all.
Caroline –
This pie got a serious downgrade in 2024. All the apples are now sliced paper thin, destroying the wonderful texture baked Northern Spy wedges get. I can’t say for sure, but it also seems like there’s less apple and more crumble this year. And this has the unfortunate side effect of making a borderline-too-sweet pie even sweeter. Still a solid premade pie, but disappointing.
W –
Eh, not nearly as good as I was hoping for given the “buttery oat crumble” description on the package. I love apple pies that have that kind of top, but this one was pretty hard (and not just pleasantly crunchy), at least the one I got. I tried it both room-temp and also heated up with vanilla ice cream. It was okay, but not something I’d buy again and definitely not as good as most apple pies I’ve had.
S –
Had a sample. More like a 3.5. A bit sweet like 8/10 in terms of sweetness. Otherwise a decent pie.